|
|
Suggestions for the improvement of Translink
(new)
on MUNI
© 2009 Bryan Costales
|
Suggestions for the improvement of Translink on MUNI
| 1. | | Automatically count boardings so that folks may benefit
from cheaper fares. For example, on the fifth boarding
of a day, stop charging and treat that pass as a daily
pass. Use a similar approach for self-calculating weekly and monthly
passes. That way a tourist can be told "put this much
on a Translink and it will be good all day (or all week)."
(Note that Oyster cards in London already do this
)
|
| 2. | | Add an annual pass to the monthly pass. Easy to do
with Translink. And, of course, an annual pass should
be less expensive than the total for 12 individual monthly passes.
|
| 3. | | Set up vending machines that sell Translink cards.
|
| A. | Take credit cards, debit cards, and cash (Note that
Caltrain ticket machines already do this).
|
| B. | Provide instructions in many languages (Note that
Caltrain ticket machines offer Spanish).
|
| C. | Allow value to be added to a card (The old BART
Translink machines did this). Note this may already
be possible, see the
translink site .
|
| D. | Allow value to be moved from one card to another.
|
| E. | Allow passes (daily, monthly, weekly) to be bought.
|
| F. | Cost for a monthly pass should be prorated to
the number of days left in a month.
|
| G. | A daily pass should really be a 24 hour card.
Good from time bought until the same time next day.
|
| H. | A weekly pass should be a 7 day pass. Good from
the time and day bought until the same time seven
days later, even if the week crosses a month's boundary.
|
| I. | If a spent card is inserted and the user ask for
a refund, refund the $5 and any remaining funds on it.
|
| J. | Locate vending machines at all major bus and
transit stops.
|
| K. | If implemented properly MUNI could phase out of accepting
cash on vehicles. But note the might require allowing
some to board without proof-of-payment in emergency
situations.
|
| 4. | | Modify inspector scanners:
|
| A. | Don't just show "YES" or "NO" but to also show
"Monthly Pass" and "Full Fare" or "Elderly"
"Disabled" etc. Otherwise Translink cards would
need to be color coded too, and color coding
Translink cards is a bad idea.
|
| B. | A monthly Translink pass should not need to be recently
tagged for an inspector's reader to show YES. That is, the presence of a valid monthly pass
should be sufficient.
|
| C. | An inspector's scanner should be able to recognize
a Translink card that has been reported stolen.
|
| D. | The user should tag the inspector's scanner, instead
of the inspector taking the Translink card away
from the customer. Not all customers will quietly
yield their card especially if the card is in a container (like a wallet)
with other valuables.
|
| E. | The inspector's scanner should work even if the
Translink card is inside a wallet.
|
| F. | The inspector's scanner should be fast. It should take less time than the present two seconds to scan.
|
| 5. | | On a bus, those with fast passes sometimes load to the
right at the front door. Other passengers at the same
time may exit to the left. One should never have
to reach across exiting passengers to tag a card. Translink
readers should be on both side of each entrance.
|
| 6. | | Translink readers should not be comfortable to lean
against. One person leaning against a reader can lead
to conflict with someone needing to tag a card.
|
| 7. | | When the Translink reader is out of service, the driver
should presume the Translink card is good. If a user
fails to tag, the driver should presume the Translink
card is good. (Note on AC Transit, a broken reader
is interpreted as a presumed paid fare.)
|
| A. | A user should never have to tag a Translink card
if it holds a Monthly (or other valid) pass. Proof
of Payment should be presumed so that boarding
is not slowed by unnecessary tagging.
|
| 8. | | When a crowd of people is exiting at certain underground stations
there is no way to enter using a Translink. At stations the
Translink readers are only located on the exits. Fast Passes
work at the entries. At an underground station, one should
never have to wait for customers to exit before entering
the station just because one is using Translink.
|
| 9. | | Translink readers on trolleys and buses can act sluggish.
Translink reader hardware should be lightening swift and
tolerant of bad swipes.
|
| A. | Like BART readers, Translink should read a card at
a distance, and one quickly waved over the reader.
|
| B. | Like BART readers, Translink readers should allow
technology to advance. Someday, cellphones may
hold Translink information.
|
| 10. | | Computational bugs should not catch the
consumer by surprise. For example, if the cash on a card is negative, a fastpass
will fail to work even if the fastpass is valid. Yet the warning beep on the tagging
device does not clarify the problem. System bugs should be fixed by Translink within
24 hours rather than being allowed to linger until normal software updates.
|
|
Related Stories: Animalblog
°
Dew Drops
°
Photofictional
°
Saturday Tales
|
|
by Bryan Costales
(1 of 23)
A new MUNIfest blog posting.
Imagine what this city would be like if elevators were run by MUNI.
|
|
|
by Bryan Costales
(2 of 23)
A alternative to bus stop elimination as a means to speed up bus travel
times. An example is given of the San Francisco MUNI 14 Mission Street
bus route.
|
|
|
by Bryan Costales
(3 of 23)
Today's MUNIfest Destiny Blog discusses why two-dimensional maps are not valuable for designing public transit routes.
|
|
|
by Bryan Costales
(4 of 23)
A Munifest Destiny Blog explores the area between buildings normally
dominated by streets, and compares car rights to pedestrian rights
based on square footage.
|
|
|
What If (689 reads, 621 days, 1 reads/day) by Bryan Costales
(5 of 23)
Imagine what it would be like if the employees of the SFMTA systems
ran the system. Would bus and trolley performance be worse or better?
|
|
|
by Bryan Costales
(6 of 23)
When a car collides with a bus or a trolley, should the driver's insurance card be presented to all the passengers so they can claim lost time?
|
|
|
by Bryan Costales
(7 of 23)
By assigning an individual credit card to each service on a translink card, the
risk of credit card fraud increases.
|
|
|
by Bryan Costales
(8 of 23)
From its inseption, the Central Subway has always presumed it would
cross Market street. But what if it didn't have to?
Whole Wheat Toast
19:29:45 Tuesday 27 July 2010
Here's a good question:
|
|
|
by Bryan Costales
(9 of 23)
A suggestion for the eight qualities that would make a superb
SFMTA board member.
|
|
|
by Bryan Costales
(10 of 23)
A proposal to earn non-resident revenue off of free residential
parking areas.
|
|
|
by Bryan Costales
(11 of 23)
The SFMTA board of directors is appointed by the mayor, not elected. How to revise the SFMTA board of directors to make them more responsive to the riding public.
|
|
|
by Bryan Costales
(12 of 23)
Without a permanent policy decision, bus and trolley fairs in San Francisco will reach $5 per ride by 2020.
|
|
|
by Bryan Costales
(13 of 23)
Anyone who walks on San Francisco's sidewalks quickly becomes aware that the pedestrian in this city
is often relegated to the lowest face on the totem pole.
By pedestrians we include anyone who
|
|
|
by Bryan Costales
(14 of 23)
Most parking meters in the city are not enforced between the hours of
6:00 p.m. and 6 a.m. which means from early evening through the following early morning.
The effect of this non-enforcement is
|
|
|
by Bryan Costales
(15 of 23)
The SFMTA (San Francisco Metropolitan Transportation Agency) announced
that it intends to impose a fare increase to the F-line. It will raise the fare
from $2.00 per ride to $5.00 per ride. The
|
|
|
by Bryan Costales
(16 of 23)
All electric buses turn left onto 3rd Street off of Townsend. The only bus that continues
straight along Townsend is the 10, a diesel bus. The below photo shows that all electric
buses turn, this
|
|
|
by Bryan Costales
(17 of 23)
As mentioned in our November 25, 2009 blog
the easternmost entry to the MUNI Embarcadero and Powell Stations,
only had a single Translink entry. This was a problem
because of the arrows on the
|
|
|
by Bryan Costales
(18 of 23)
For the first few years of the N-Line's extension out the Embarcadero to 4th and King, bars were embedded
into both platform edges. (See the above photograph.) The idea appeared
to be for the bars
|
|
|
by Bryan Costales
(19 of 23)
At the easternmost entry to the MUNI Embarcadero and Powell Stations,
only a single Translink entry exists. This is a problem
because of the arrows on the other side:
Notice how all the arrows
|
|
|
by Bryan Costales
(20 of 23) If you have ever tried to read, write, film,
or just plain want to remain steady on a MUNI bus,
you will be dissapointed. Almost every bus route
leads those poor bus tires over pot holes, bad
street
|
|
|
by Bryan Costales
(21 of 23) Should MUNI be Fare Free?
One Man's Opinion
The question is whether or not MUNI should be fare supported
or should be converted to become fare-free.
Rather than decide in advance that a fare-free
|
|
|
by Bryan Costales
(22 of 23)
A Future San Francisco Subway System
Here we present in diagrammatic a view of what the San Francisco subway system might
evolve into when the population of the city doubles then triples.
It is
|
|